The UN’s privacy expert says the rules for moving personal data across borders have become a patchwork. Ana Brian Nougrères, the UN Special Rapporteur on the right to privacy, reported to the General Assembly in October. She said the patchwork exposes people to privacy risks and creates barriers to legitimate trade, and urged states to begin negotiations on a legally binding international instrument on data transfers.
A payment, a customer check or a trade document often needs data to cross a border before it can move.
The report looks at adequacy decisions, standard contractual clauses, binding corporate rules and other instruments. Its conclusion is that “none of the instruments analysed is sufficient on their own”. How well each works depends on strong national protections, capable supervisors and political commitment. The report asks companies to build privacy into their systems, set clear transfer policies and run impact assessments. It also calls for practical, low cost tools for developing countries.
Why payments feel it
The Financial Stability Board made the payments case in December 2024. It said moving data across borders is essential to how cross border payments work. Rules that keep data in one country can delay or even stop payments. They also make fraud, money laundering and sanctions checks harder, and make it harder to manage risk across a whole bank. Incomplete data can cause transactions to fail and break straight through processing. The FSB cited an OECD estimate that localisation could raise data management costs by 15 to 55%, depending on the measure.
A 2023 Global Privacy Assembly census, cited by the FSB, found that 90% of jurisdictions have laws restricting transfers of personal data abroad, up from 83% in 2020. Over the same period, the share of authorities requiring local data processing facilities fell from 27% to 17%.
Washington has made data a trade issue too. Michael Geist is a law professor. By his reading, the US 2026 report on foreign trade barriers identifies more than 30 countries that restrict cross border data access. Among the financial examples he cites is the Reserve Bank of India’s requirement that all payment system data be stored in India. He also cites strict localisation rules from Indonesia’s financial regulator for financial transactions, and a Turkish central bank ban on cloud services for certain financial workloads. Geist argues the US is using the CLOUD Act to reach data wherever it sits, and trade policy to press countries that try to keep their data beyond that reach.
The FSB points to privacy enhancing technologies, which let data be analysed while it stays with its owner. It says uptake is held back by limited understanding among market participants and the lack of a regulatory safe harbour.
What it means for trade finance
Trade finance runs on identity, ownership and payment data, and a bank needs to know who stands behind each party before it releases funds. That information often sits in more than one country. The UN report recommends a binding instrument but cannot make governments negotiate one, so for now banks work with rules written country by country.
Related on Digital Trade Outlook
- When Sanctions Target the Bank and Not Just the Buyer, Banks Become Gatekeepers and Exporters Could Feel It First
- Five Hong Kong Banks Now Check Mainland Customs Data. The Harder Part Comes Next
- ASEAN’s DEFA Moves Digital Trade Rulemaking Beyond the WTO
Image: United Nations emblem and Financial Stability Board logo
